Lord Lilley:
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Docherty of Milngavie, to congratulate him on his excellent and witty speech and to welcome him to your Lordships’ House, where he will no longer have to depend on the votes of his opponents or anybody else to retain his seat.
The noble Lord was very modest in his speech and did not mention his professional career as chief executive of Tees Valley Regeneration and executive director of the Home Group, one of the biggest UK social enterprises. He also did not mention his passion for the arts, which I look forward to hearing about in future speeches. He was a founding trustee of the Baltic gallery in Gateshead and commissioned Anish Kapoor’s Temenos in Middlesbrough, which features on the British passport. He was also a trustee of Arts Council England. In an interview last year, he said:
“What gives me joy … is when I have been involved in recruiting people who have gone on to excel and grow in their roles”.
He has excelled and grown in his roles up to now and will continue to do so, no doubt, in your Lordships’ House.
As far as trade relations are concerned, Britain is to the EU much as Canada is to the United States of America. We both have free trade agreements with zero tariffs and zero quotas with our large continental neighbour. Neither Britain nor Canada has a customs union or a single market requiring it to adopt the tariffs and all the product Laws and standards of its large neighbour. Yet I know of no Canadians who, even pre-Trump, ever advocated Canada joining a customs union, still less dynamically aligning its laws and standards with those of America.
Can the noble Lord, Lord Newby, tell us why a customs union or single market is good for Britain but would be bad for Canada—or vice versa? Why did he not tell us that a customs union would require Britain to reinstate the over 2,000 tariffs on goods that we do not produce, which we abolished when we left the EU? Why should British consumers pay higher prices to protect inefficient EU producers? For example, since Brexit we have allowed a tariff-free quota of sugar, which costs $449 a tonne coming from Brazil. Back in the customs union, it would cost us $892 per tonne from France. Vote Lib Dems for higher prices. A customs union would also mean scrapping our trade agreements with the Pacific trade pact, the largest grouping by GDP in the world, and with India, the largest country by population, with which our trade deal has important service industry chapters.
The sole benefit of a customs union is that it avoids the need for declarations of origin. The Swiss calculate that these cost less than 0.02% of the value of their trade with Europe. Hence Switzerland, like Norway and Iceland, refuses to join the EU customs union. Turkey does have a customs union with the EU, but that means that when the EU negotiates a free trade deal with another country, Turkey has to remove its tariffs on that other country’s goods, but the other country does not have to remove its tariffs on Turkey’s goods. Is that what the Lib Dems want?
I was the Trade and Industry Secretary who oversaw Britain’s entry into and creation of the open market back in 1992, and I assumed it would benefit our trade. I also negotiated the Uruguay trade round, the last successful world trade agreement, which halved tariffs and created the WTO. I made bullish speeches about how both of these, particularly the single market, would boost British exports. A quarter of a century later, a study showed how British exports had actually fared. I confess it proved that I had been wrong. Britain’s goods exports to the single market stagnated over nearly 25 years, growing by less than 1% a year. By contrast, our goods exports to more than 100 countries with whom we traded solely on WTO terms grew fourfold, by 87%.
I have long been at a loss to explain why anyone should want to return to a relationship with our former partners that was of so little benefit to us and would involve handing back control of our laws and our tariffs and paying for the privilege of doing so, but a psychotherapist friend explained to me that people who have escaped from a long-term coercive relationship often have an irrational urge to return to the partner who controlled their lives, dictated how they spent, made them subject to detailed and unnecessary rules and restricted their relationships with anyone else. I think we should be understanding of the noble Lord, Lord Newby, and, indeed, the Government’s European Minister as they endeavour to recover from this syndrome, and gently point out that others who once succumbed to coercive control from the EU, such as the National Farmers’ Union, now warn against returning to the ban on gene-edited crops and bovine TB vaccines and ending the ban on live animal exports. The City now wants to be excluded from any reset and has allegedly, according to the Financial Times, persuaded the Government that that would be right. The AI industry rejoices in escaping from the stifling controls of EU law. I wish the Lib Dems and their friends on the Labour Benches a speedy recovery from their addiction to coercive control.
Lord Razzall:
My Lords, having listened to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, in the past, I am sure noble Lords will accept that I do not agree with much of what he said. The context in which we are discussing this is, to me, the obvious failure of the Brexit project. I take the comments made by the noble Lord, Lord Lamont, about the 4% of GDP spread over a period, but I would prefer to look at the recent figures from the National Bureau of Economic Research, a well-respected American organisation, that says the cost to us of Brexit has been between 6% and 8%, which, aggregated, is something like £95 billion of our GDP.
I think the other thing that is worth commenting on, which nobody has—unfortunately the noble Lord, Lord Gove, has left the Chamber—is that one of the things that the Brexit debate entrenched in our culture is that political lying is all right. Where is the money we were promised on the side of the bus for the NHS? Where are all the Turkish immigrants we were promised in the emails that were sent to people in the last two weeks of the campaign? This, to me, has been the absolute zenith of lies and nadir of results. I take the point that has been made about some trade deals having been entered into, but most of the trade deals that were entered into by the new regime were simply Snopaking out “EU” and substituting “UK” in those trade deals. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, referred to the CPTPP, but the estimate of the impact of that on our trade deals is infinitely less than the cost of losing the opportunities that we had with the European Union.
I do not know whether our friends in the Labour Party, who were referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, include the Prime Minister, who in May 2025 clearly indicated that he wanted to reset our arrangements with the European Union. This has not been terribly successful so far. Obviously, the progress on Erasmus has been good, but we have pulled out of the attempts to participate in the €150 billion European Defence Fund, we have not been able to deal with the internal electricity market, which we thought we would be able to do, and the phytosanitary agreement, which somebody over there mentioned earlier, that we hoped that we would get has not yet happened.
We have been asked to say what we mean by a customs union. Now Al Pinkerton, the MP, ironically, for Surrey Heath—he replaced the noble Lord, Lord Gove—argued for a bespoke customs union deal with the EU, not including agriculture, with consultation on all trade deals. It should be a bespoke deal. He proposed that in a Bill in the House of Commons and it went through, with some Labour people supporting him. It will not get into legislation, but it did pass. Turkey has had that arrangement since 1995. Why can we not have it?
Lord Doyle:
My Lords, I rise for my maiden speech with a real sense of the responsibility that comes with joining a body so rich in experience, expertise and public service as your Lordships’ House. I thank Black Rod, the indefatigable doorkeepers, the police and security officers, the clerks and officials and everyone who has made me feel so welcome. I also thank my noble friends Lady Armstrong of Hill Top and Lord Liddell for their support and guidance, not only at my introduction but over many years, and I pay tribute to my fellow maiden speakers today.
I am profoundly grateful that my parents are here today. When I say that I would not be here without them, I do not just mean that scientifically. They taught me so much, above all that every single individual can make a difference, and when you are born into that way of being, it really is a gift. I also remember my sister Catherine, who we lost more than 30 years ago; we still miss her every single day. Catherine was born with Down syndrome and, although she did not live to see it, the progress that has been made in healthcare and opportunities and visibility for people living with Down really has been wonderful to witness.
My journey here began at the University of East Anglia, where I joined the Labour Club and met an inspiring dean of biology, Dr Ian Gibson, who was Labour’s candidate for Norwich North. One day, they asked for a volunteer press officer: cue awkward shoe-gazing around me, and then suddenly I found my hand in the air. Little did I know that I would spend the next three decades at the intersection of politics, media and public service. I may have worked for some famous names in that time, but the real privilege I have had has been helping to tell the stories of those who have been left out and left behind, both at home and abroad. I pay tribute to and thank all the colleagues I have worked with over those years, many of whom are now here in this House, including my noble friends Lord Kennedy of Southwark and Lady Smith of Basildon, who I thank for all their guidance and support thus far.
I also want to remember two former Members of this House in particular: Lord Gould of Brookwood and Baroness McDonagh, both of whom were remarkable inspirations for me.
I chose Great Barford for my introduction. It is where my sister and I were born. This is an exciting time for Bedfordshire, with East West Rail, the new Universal Studios theme park and, at Tempsford, a new town. I intend to champion these projects and more, because Britain needs to stop prevaricating and start building. Growth is not an abstract theory but an expression of our responsibility to future generations.
One of the privileges I had growing up in Bedfordshire was a fantastic free county youth music programme. The inspiring teaching gave me opportunities I could never have imagined, including the chance to sing at the Royal Albert Hall. Fortunately for the audience, I sang with several other hundred young people as well. But somewhere along the way, we seem to have lost the consensus that the arts, music, film, theatre and dance matter as an essential means of developing confident, creative and capable citizens. I very much hope that the Government’s curriculum review will mark a decisive turning point in rebuilding a shared understanding that creativity, culture and learning are key to what makes life worth living, as well as essential drivers of our national success.
It is my belief in the creative industries that made me so keen to make my maiden speech in this debate on our relations with Europe. There is much we can do to reduce self-defeating barriers post-Brexit. Take the example of touring artists and crews. For them, those barriers are not an abstract concept but lost work, lost income and lost opportunity. This does not have to be our reality. Let us fix the visa waiver programme, flex the 90-day rule for those touring and cut the costs to make moving equipment less expensive, which has also done such harm to our haulage industry. As Sir Elton John put it:
“It’s heartbreaking to see the hopes of Britain’s next generation of creative talent downtrodden and destroyed by bureaucracy and red tape”.
When I nervously collected my first parliamentary pass almost 30 years ago, I could not possibly have imagined that one day I would stand here as a Member of your Lordships’ House. I have learned so much over my career, but I have never lost sight of that simple lesson my parents taught me: that change is made by people and that the world does not improve by chance. Government matters because it gives individual effort collective backing. It allows values to be translated into action and hope into reality. As we consider our future relationship with Europe, we must recommit ourselves to the values we share: dignity, respect, democracy and the rule of law. Because even in these times—especially in these times—I believe that when we choose purpose over complacency and co-operation over conflict, progress is possible.
Lord Liddle:
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to welcome my new colleagues who are making their maiden speeches today—my noble friends Lady Gill and Lord Docherty, my good friend who is to come later, and my noble friend Lord Doyle, who is a very close friend and from whom we have just heard an excellent maiden speech. I first came across my noble friend 30 years ago, when he had just arrived in Westminster and was working for the newly elected Labour MPs for East Anglia. He was so keen on this job and he was homeless, so he camped out in Charles Clarke’s office while he sorted out his personal affairs. He always had that trademark, and he has kept it: he is the man with the duffel coat. He always reminds me, whenever I see him, of Paddington Bear. In a way, that is appropriate, because he is a man of great culture and a real expert on film, so he will bring great wisdom on cultural questions to this House.
In the past 30 years since I first met my noble friend, he has done a great variety of very interesting things. He has worked intimately with some of the most consequential people on the centre-left of British politics: first for Tony Blair in No. 10 and then in his role as Middle East peace envoy, then for David Miliband—Labour’s lost leader—in his role with the International Rescue Committee, and finally for Keir Starmer. Working for Keir Starmer, he was not one of the fast-rotating group of people who have been in and out of No. 10; he was a crucial aide. I do know how many people know this, but he sustained Keir Starmer at what was the deepest crisis point of his leadership of the Labour Party after the loss of the Hartlepool By-election in 2021. When he worked on the Batley and Spen by-election, he persuaded Kim Leadbeater, Jo Cox’s sister, to be our candidate and we squeezed home by 300 votes. That is probably one of the most consequential acts of his political career. In his three decades of politics, has shown outstanding loyalty to the bosses he has worked for.
My noble friend is a very considerable person. He is a man of faith who has struggled with some of his inner tensions and conflicts and overcome them. He brings to this House much more than the experience of a press officer; he is well informed across a wide range of national and international issues. He is a committed lifelong social democrat and he is going to make a great contribution to this House.
On the subject of the debate, I will not delay the House long, but I will say this. I have great respect for the intellect of the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, but I have never heard such rubbish on the question of Europe. He referred to his role in the Uruguay round. Let me remind him, it was the European Commission that negotiated the Uruguay round.
Lord Lilley:
In fact, it was jointly negotiated by member states and the European Commission. I was there for all nine days of the negotiations in the Heysel stadium, so the noble Lord is wrong.
Lord Liddle:
Do you know why we won the Uruguay round? It is because we had the strength of the bloc of the European Union behind us. It was not just something that Britain achieved on its own.
Secondly, the noble Lord talks about the stagnation in our export of goods and completely ignores the vast expansion of our trade in services with the European Union, which is being put at risk by increasing barriers. He neglects the fact that, in 2016, the British public were promised a growth miracle as a result of leaving the EU. Where are the benefits of all that loosening of rules that were supposed to happen? We were promised the end of free movement, and what did the Conservatives do? They went on to create the biggest inward movement of people into this country we have ever seen, so what hypocrisy they have talked on immigration. If we had stayed in the single market and in Europe, the growth we would have seen as a result would have meant that none of the tax rises that we needed to have since the 2024 General Election would have been necessary. Those are facts.
The economic situation is getting worse as we lose the strength of the European bloc. We no longer have the competitive pressure of the single market, which is what makes business efficient. As we lose that competitive pressure, we will find that Brexit is not a one-off loss; it will affect our competitive position for years to come.
I said I would not talk for long, but may I just make one point? We should look at the customs union and try to speed up the reset. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Hannay: we need independent expert advice on what we would try to achieve and how. This is something of great complexity. We need to look objectively at the consequences of having an independent trade policy. I do not think they are very considerable, but I am willing to be proved wrong in an independent expert inquiry, which I hope Keir Starmer will set up.
