That is the uncompromising message delivered today by the Rt Hon Peter Lilley MP, a member of the Thatcher and Major cabinets.
In a paper published today (Taking Liberties, published by the Adam Smith
Institute), Lilley argues that four fundamental pillars of freedom, jury
trial, Double Jeopardy, Presumption of Innocence, and Habeas Corpus are
threatened by an unprecedented alliance between populism (to sound tough on
crime) and modernizing zeal. The net result will be to make the British
people more vulnerable than ever to arbitrary action by the State.
Recognizing the importance of tackling rising crime, Lilley warns that
sacrificing the liberties which protect the innocent will not help bring the
guilty to justice: indeed every time an innocent person is committed the
real culprit is left free to commit more crimes.
He describes the new proposals as the first step in “the most comprehensive
assault on the jury system” ever proposed, and demolishes the arguments used
to justify it. He points out that the government?s two central arguments
actually contradict each other. One is the claim that juries hand down
shorter sentences and more acquittals, and the other is that money will be
saved if jury cases decline because of the smaller sentences expected from
magistrates? courts.
As for the claim that two-thirds of those choosing jury trial eventually
plead guilty, Lilley says yes, but to a lesser charge. And while two thirds
(not 90 percent as the government claim) of those opting for jury trial who
are convicted have previous convictions, this shows that those with previous
convictions expect a fairer trial from a jury. The higher acquittal rate
reflects the fact that those with the stronger cases prefer jury trials.
The jury system is under attack, says Lilley, because some lawyers basically
distrust ordinary citizens to get it right. They resent the role which
non-professionals play. they attack jury trial from both ends, with the
claim that some cases are too simple to require juries, while others are too
complex for juries to handle. Not true, says Lilley, pointing out that the
Serious Fraud Office has a 92% conviction rate in fraud cases.
He makes six powerful points in favour of juries:
… Juries are independent of the state and its judicial and police systems.
… Jury trial is the best protection for the innocent.
… Jury trial enjoys public confidence not least among ethnic minorities.
… Juries will not enforce laws that grossly offend their sense of justice.
… Juries involve ordinary people (nearly 200,000 every year) in the
judicial system.
… Jury trial commands respect even among the guilty.
“Trial by jury, and the right to choose it, remains the most effective
safeguard against the risk of arbitrary persecution of the individual by the
State,” concludes Lilley. He puts forward proposals to strengthen jury trial
and widen participation in juries.
Double Jeopardy
Lilley is similarly alarmed by threats to the 800 year-old Double Jeopardy
rule which prevents a person, once acquitted, being tried again for the same
offence. The Law Commission, spurred on by the Macpherson report on the
Stephen Lawrence case, opted for weakening Double Jeopardy in three cases.
It must be limited to murder, the new evidence must be compelling, and must
not have been available at the first trial.
But, claims Lilley, “it will be hard to prevent the exception being
progressively widened to include serious crimes.” He shows that no other
country which allows exceptions to the Double Jeopardy rule has limited them
to murder.
Furthermore, the jury will be influenced by knowing that appeal court judges
have found the new evidence to be compelling. We already stop trials when
jurors are influenced by newspaper reports; yet this will affect even more
their ability to be unbiased.
As for evidence which was not available at the first trial, Lilley explains
that cases might be much less rigorously prepared if prosecutors know they
can always come back for another go.
He lists four powerful reasons why the Double Jeopardy rule protects
liberties.
… It protects the individual from harassment by the state or other
prosecutors.
… It gives the police and the prosecution an incentive to prepare their
case thoroughly before it comes to court.
… It gives innocent people peace of mind, once acquitted.
… It prevents a second jury being prejudiced by knowing that a retrial
implies compelling new evidence of guilt.
“Is it worth undermining an 800 year-old principle,” he asks, “to rectify a
few past cases even though this will have no deterrent effect on crime in
future?”
Presumption of Innocence & Habeas Corpus
As well as the threats to jury trials and Double Jeopardy, Lilley identifies
major erosion of the Presumption of Innocence rule. “Recent government
legislation shows a disturbing disregard for it,” he says. He cites cases
involving truckers and asylum seekers, and football fans who can be
arrested, detained and prevented from travelling abroad unless they can
prove they are not potential hooligans.
He cites European Directives on sex and race discrimination, in which the
onus is on the employer to prove that “in all probability” they did not
discriminate directly or indirectly.
Even Habeas Corpus, that bedrock of English liberties deriving from Magna
Carta, is under threat. The Government?s Anti-Terrorism Act 2001 and, above
all, the proposed EU Arrest Warrant attack its very foundation. Lilley
indicates that “Belgium could issue an arrest warrant covering someone
living in Britain relating to an offence committed in Germany.” And they
could be handed over to a foreign state without any of the protection which
Habeas Corpus gives them against potential abuse by our own system.
“This fourfold attack on our freedoms,” concludes Lilley, “reflects a
political alliance of populism and modernizing zeal.” “I believe,” he tells
us, “that freedom, as we in these islands have come to understand and value
it, requires limits to be set on the role of the state.”
It is because he believes that those limits have been and are being
transgressed that he issues today?s salvo.
